Aaron – Citadel
Without cracking into the true Gothenburg Melo-Death bands, of which I’ve almost completely grown out of, I found myself running short on albums I could consider Prog Melodic Death. DD is definitely more of a traditional Doom band, but hey, gotta nuke somethin’. “Citadel” owns this matchup.
Scrodge – Citadel
NE OBLIVISCARIS – “Citadel” has got my vote. Both are great albums. “Citadel” has a few more upbeat parts. The violin really hones the tone, it gives a few songs a nice waltz feel.
Luke Rager
Ne Obliviscaris. Painters of the Tempest is so damn good. The violin solo into guitar solo is *chef’s kiss*. Feels yo. Obviously, I dig the DD album but never really considered it prog.
Drucifer
Lemme get a jump start – my vote is for ne obliscaris. I completely forgot about daylight dies, especially this album, which i used to rock on a constant basis. It was nostalgic but also acted like a time capsule for me
Krychek – Citadel
NeO this round. Dismantling is great, but I’m not sure it’s even my favourite by them.
Moe – Citadel
Oh AND…Nay! Ob…Daylight Days was…fine. Shit it was even good. But Ne Obliviscaris is just too much good stuff at once.
Brian – Citadel
Daylight Dies is pretty vanilla; respect though. Ne Obliviscaris wins this round with several dominant tracks
The Progress Report 
This round I will go with NE OBLIVISCARIS. I like the violin in the mix.
LikeLike
Aaron – Citadel
Without cracking into the true Gothenburg Melo-Death bands, of which I’ve almost completely grown out of, I found myself running short on albums I could consider Prog Melodic Death. DD is definitely more of a traditional Doom band, but hey, gotta nuke somethin’. “Citadel” owns this matchup.
Scrodge – Citadel
NE OBLIVISCARIS – “Citadel” has got my vote. Both are great albums. “Citadel” has a few more upbeat parts. The violin really hones the tone, it gives a few songs a nice waltz feel.
Luke Rager
Ne Obliviscaris. Painters of the Tempest is so damn good. The violin solo into guitar solo is *chef’s kiss*. Feels yo. Obviously, I dig the DD album but never really considered it prog.
Drucifer
Lemme get a jump start – my vote is for ne obliscaris. I completely forgot about daylight dies, especially this album, which i used to rock on a constant basis. It was nostalgic but also acted like a time capsule for me
Krychek – Citadel
NeO this round. Dismantling is great, but I’m not sure it’s even my favourite by them.
Moe – Citadel
Oh AND…Nay! Ob…Daylight Days was…fine. Shit it was even good. But Ne Obliviscaris is just too much good stuff at once.
Brian – Citadel
Daylight Dies is pretty vanilla; respect though. Ne Obliviscaris wins this round with several dominant tracks
LikeLike